Whole Grains of Truth

[***Editor’s Note: At times the wonderful world of social media can be a tad confusticating. The recent issue surrounding the case of Dr. Hoffe is a good example of what can happen when otherwise well-meaning, conscientious supporters send out information to the net that’s not fully correct and which ends up spawning confusion as to what’s actually going on.

Shit happens like this all the time and I’m just as guilty of it as anyone else, especially when one is working in the field and the field is now so immense that it’s easy to trip over the keys on one’s pc and send something out without having fully checked it out.

Setting the record straight is always helpful, even in retrospect and that’s what this post is for.

I received the following email below from Dr. Hoffe’s lawyer, Michael Alexander, last evening and I’m posting it and the original statement that ended up slipping into the Rumour Mill.]

Re: Status of Dr. Hoffe’s case

Hi Arthur,

I’m sorry to be so delayed in getting back to you. I’ve been very wrapped up in getting the adjournment for Charles, which was successful.

Here is the original statement, which I had misplaced on my computer. It’s the same as below, but it contains a paragraph that Vaccine Choice excluded. I’m sure this is too late to go press. But, if you wanted to report on the latest news, which you may done already, it would be that we did get the adjournment, and I will putting out a press release shortly about what this means going forward.

Best wishes,

Michael Alexander,MA, JD, LLM

LITIGATIONWORKSMerchandise Building155 Dalhousie Street,

Suite 410Toronto, 

ON M5B 2P7

Direct: 416-318-4512

Re: Status of Dr. Hoffe’s case

An unidentified party sent out an e-mail regarding Dr. Hoffe’s case on the weekend, and it has caused considerable misunderstanding and harm. Dr. Hoffe and I have reviewed the e-mail, and Dr. Hoffe has authorized me to correct misapprehensions resulting from it.

First, I have not missed any deadlines for Dr. Hoffe or any of my other physician clients. Dr. Hoffe was scheduled for a hearing at the College of Physicians in BC, which was to begin on February 12th. However, I experienced a serious adverse health event just before Christmas and ended up in the ER, and I am still recovering from the episode. Shortly after being discharged from the hospital, I notified the College that I would need an adjournment of the hearing on health grounds. At that time, all filing deadlines were provisionally suspended. Subsequently, I provided a medical note to the College in pursuit of the adjournment. Later today, February 7th, my external counsel in BC will appear at a College case conference to formally present the request for a re-scheduling of Dr. Hoffe’s hearing.

Second, Dr. Hoffe was charged under the old Health Professions Act. It is by no means clear at this point that the College has a right to try him under the new legislation, with its enhanced penalties. Those who suggest otherwise have jumped the gun.

Third, this e-mail was brought to my attention on Saturday evening when I attended the dinner for the Justice for the Vaccinated Conference in Toronto. During the pre-dinner reception, I learned that an attendee was spreading false information about my conduct of the Hoffe case and other physician cases on my docket. I had a meeting with her at the end of the evening in the presence of conference organizers. We had a professional and civilized conversation, and I was able to disabuse her of her mistaken views. However, another e-mail was soon circulated stating that we had been engaged in a “fight.” That is not true. The matter was resolved amicably. 

Finally, some of the people who circulated the original e-mail know me or have social media connections with me. They could easily have reached out to me for clarification. If they had, this whole affair, which has been damaging for me and Dr. Hoffe, might been stopped in its tracks. Social media is a great way for us to share information and remain united in our efforts, but when it degenerates and becomes a rumour mill, as in this case, it harms the very people we are trying to help. Please think twice before tweeting, texting or posting unsubstantiated claims. 

Michael Alexander, JD


Hearing of BC Doctor Who Spoke Out Against COVID Protocols Postponed by Regulatory College

A sign for a COVID-19 vaccination clinic run by Vancouver Coastal Health in Richmond, B.C., on April 10, 2021. (The Canadian Press/Jonathan Hayward)
By Jeff Sandes
February 12, 2023Updated: February 12, 2023

[Editor’s Note: It’s with great relief that news of Dr. Hoffe’s hearing before the College of Physicians and Surgeons of BC has been postponed and I want to thank all the good folks across the nation who were so conscientiously quick in firing off letters of support for Charles Hoffe to the College of Physicians and Surgeons of BC. BIG THANKS also to Jeff Sandes and the Epoch Times for running his story.

Please note that the images in the body of the article and any urls attached to them are mine and not those of Epoch Times.]

Hearing of BC Doctor Who Spoke Out Against
COVID Protocols Postponed by Regulatory College

By Jeff Sandes

The first doctor in British Columbia to face a disciplinary hearing in front of the province’s College of Physicians and Surgeons related to COVID-19 protocol has had his review postponed.

Lytton, B.C. before the fire

Dr. Charles Hoffe from Lytton, B.C., was scheduled to begin his 10-day hearing before a college discipline committee panel on Feb. 13, but his lawyer, who spent several weeks in hospital recently, had applied multiple times to postpone the hearing so he could prepare. After a case conference on Feb. 7 and 8, the panel notified Hoffe and his lawyer of the adjournment on Feb. 9. A new date for his hearing has not yet been publicly announced.

Hoffe says he’s relieved.

“We initially asked for this adjournment seven and a half weeks ago, but the college was so reluctant to give it that they’ve literally approved it four days before the trial starts,” he told The Epoch Times.

“Clearly, they have done this with great reluctance. But you know, time and truth go hand in hand, and with every passing week, more and more scientific evidence validates everything they have accused me of, showing they are wrong. So they clearly need to drop all of these absurd charges against me and all of the other doctors, and they need to go back to [being] the guardians of medical ethics, which is what they’re supposed to be.”

The citation listed three examples, with more left unnamed. Hoffe is accused of recommending ivermectin as a treatment for COVID and where to get it without a prescription; saying COVID vaccines can cause harm including neurological injuries, female infertility, and even death not recognized by public health; and expressing that vaccinated people can cause harm to those who remain vaccine free.


Many of Hoffe’s supporters wrote to the college in recent weeks to show their opposition to any disciplinary action against Hoffe.

In a citation issued to Hoffe in February 2022, the college alleged he “contravened standards imposed under the Health Professions Act, including but not limited to the Canadian Medical Association’s Code of Ethics and Professionalism by publishing statements on social media and other digital platforms that were misleading, incorrect or inflammatory about vaccinations, treatments, and public measure relating to COVID-19.”

Former police officer Ivan DeSilva used to work with the college when he was a detective with the Vancouver Police Department’s Sex Crimes and Child Abuse units, handling many of their investigations.

DeSilva now hosts his “A Biblical Frame” podcast. He has interviewed Hoffe on his podcast, having previously met him, and as a supporter he wrote a letter to the college speaking to Hoffe’s professionalism and integrity.

See article HERE

He says the college now operates with a different mandate than when he was with the Vancouver Police Department.

“When I wrote this letter, I basically said there was a time when I worked with the college and their investigative body and saw how they did their investigations,” DeSilva said in an interview. “I developed respect for them, and it is out of that sense of high regard for them that I’m surprised that they’re taking this approach with Dr. Hoffe because it doesn’t seem to gel with the college I knew.”

Now he says he wonders whether the college has “become another political tool of the government.”

DeSilva says the recent passing of Bill 36, the Health Professions and Occupations Act, suggests to him the B.C. government is looking to replace medical professionals in the province’s colleges with government bureaucrats, which could compromise their integrity.

The Epoch Times reached out to the College of Physicians and Surgeons of British Columbia but did not receive a reply.


Hoffe created controversy in April 2021 when he wrote an open letter to B.C. Provincial Health Officer Bonnie Henry describing the severe adverse events some of his patients were experiencing after receiving the COVID vaccines, and asking whether the province should reconsider the rollout.

See Cariboosentinel article HERE

“In our small community of Lytton, BC, we have one person dead, and three people who look as though they will be permanently disabled, following their first dose of the Moderna vaccine. The age of those affected ranges from 38 to 82 years of age,” he wrote.

Before writing the letter, Hoffe had been censored from communicating with other doctors about side effects and the person he was told to direct all of his questions to at Interior Health ignored his repeated requests to address his concerns, he says. He was banned from working in provincial hospitals and all of his submissions of vaccine adverse events were overturned and deemed to be coincidence.

See Cariboosentinel article HERE

Former Newfoundland and Labrador premier Brian Peckford also wrote to the college in support of Hoffe and highlighted its lack of adherence to the Charter of Rights and Freedoms, a document he helped create.

“I urge you to abandon your present course and permit Dr. Hoffe to continue his excellent medical practice providing care in freedom, valuing the right of the person and in practicing the principle of doing no harm,” Peckford wrote.

“May I remind you of the Charter provision of ‘life, liberty and security of the person.’ This is in Canada’s most important document, our Constitution.”

The Epoch Times contacted the B.C. Ministry of Health asking about oversight of the college and whether provisions in Bill 36 were designed to provide additional protections to the college or its members, but did not receive a response by press time.


Dr. Hoffe & Dr. Malthouse Speaking in Quesnel January 15, 2022

[UPDATE: (Thurs. Jan 6 11:47 PM) A number of people have replied to an email send out stating that the url to this story is malfunctioning. I’m still trying to figure out what the problem is. More importantly though the Cariboo Sentinel received the following email from Dr. Hoffe:

Dear Arthur,
Unfortunately, for personal reasons, I have needed to stand down from the northern section of our doctor’s speaking tour. So unfortunately I will not be coming to Quesnel.
Thank you for your part and our fight for freedom and truth.
Kindest regards,Charles
Charles Hoffe MD


I will continue to post further information on whether Dr. Malthouse will be on the tour when I find out out.]


[Editor’s Note: Upcoming candidate for Mayor of Quesnel in 2022 Tami Viktil has announced on her fb group Rise Up Quesnel that Dr. Hoffe and Dr. Malhouse, who are currently on a Speaking Tour, will be coming to Quesnel on Saturday, January 15th, 2022 to speak on issues related to BC’s Vaccination program.

The location for the Medical Information Session will be announced as soon as a venue is confirmed. I will post the location here on the site when it has been established. Please share this post with as many of your friends and relatives and associates as you can. Thanks]

Heroes No Longer – Episode 2 – Doctor Charles Hoffe

Rumble — This interview was removed from youtube due to it being reported by someone. It had received 55,000 views before it was taken down. Freedom of speech is dying.

Doctor Charles Hoffe of Lytton BC, one of the few doctors in our province willing to speak about that which is forbidden to discuss. Because of this, Charles has sacrificed a great deal. Thank you for all you’ve done and continue to do, Doctor Hoffe.

To help me continue to produce this series please consider donating – https://gofund.me/ffe6b246

EDITORIAL: The Esoteric/Occult Side of Life

EDITORIAL: The Esoteric/Occult Side of Life


Arthur Topham

Editor, Quesnel Cariboo Sentinel

We are living at a time that might best be described as extraordinary. Events, of late, have disrupted the normal flow of life to the point where people are not only confused, doubtful and fearful but are suddenly realizing that something is dreadfully wrong in the world; a world which they once unfailingly took for granted.  

There’s a metaphoric tectonic shift occurring within the fundamental superstructure upon which humanity once firmly stood in much the same manner that people viewed the cosmos around them prior to the revelations of Astronomer Nicolaus Copernicus who, in 1512, correctly ascertained that our planet was definitely not the centre of the universe. 

The growing realization that planet Earth is now under siege by a dark and sinister force determined to undermine the very principles by which humanity has lived to its best ability since the advent of the Renaissance has come upon us like a sudden clap of thunder sending jolts of shock and bewilderment and panic throughout societies everywhere.

For those who, for various reasons, cannot fathom that their government, media and health authorities could possibly be conspiring with other governments around the world in what can only be described as the greatest hoax upon humanity in recorded history, their only option has been to accept the massive lie as truth and do their best to follow and adjust their lives to whatever commandments are issued by their government and health representatives. For these people their only sanctuary is to believe that everything they’re being told to do is in their best interests and the interests of the public at large.

While this type of behaviour on their part may appear to be the only laudable and safe way of dealing with the Covid-19 hoax the reality that they are as mistaken as their leaders who, in turn, are willingly culpable in this egregious crime against humanity becomes more blatantly obvious with each passing day and with every new report coming through on the Internet from doctors and scientists and medical practitioners around the world that tears to shreds the government/media/WHO narrative revealing it to be nothing more than a sinister act of colossal deception steeped in a heinous agenda to deliberately murder millions of innocent human beings.  

Faced with this unprecedented global crisis now afflicting all of humanity, individuals are being forced to ponder and search for answers to that proverbial, nagging question – who benefits from these sudden, draconian decrees emanating forth from leaders around the world whose repetitious, deceptive pronouncements are becoming more painfully obvious with each passing day? 

It is at this juncture in our quest for answers to this controversial topic that the notion of a hidden agenda forces its way into the consciousness of the mass of citizens; those who already know intuitively or by signals coming from their gut that there’s more to this treacherous quandary than what meets the eye. Thus the search for truth must circumvent the veil of mainstream media propaganda where tv’s and daily newspapers suddenly become obsolete instruments for seeking out any meaningful answers. Now seekers must recognize the necessity of pulling back the veil in order to look for the hidden or occult reasons for why the planet and its lifeforms are in such imminent danger of being genocided through the use of poisoned injections designed to kill off or cripple millions of souls. 

Donovan Leitch, one of the balladeers of the 1960’s Hippie Movement, described the times we’re now in as the “Season of the Witch” and thus it behooves those who would know the answers to the perplexing questions surrounding events of the moment to cast aside their programmed prejudices toward all things of this nature, suspend their disbelief and critically examine the evidence hitherto hidden from the public domain. 

The Concise Oxford Dictionary tells us that the word “esoteric” is an adjective and describes it as follows: “(Of philosophical doctrines, etc.) meant only for the initiated; (of disciples) initiated; private, confidential.” The term “occult”, also an adjective, is defined thus: “Kept secret, esoteric; recondite, mysterious, beyond the range of ordinary knowledge; involving the supernatural, mystical, magical.”

So the obvious question then for anyone wishing to delve into such subjects is: where can I find information pertaining to these formerly secret philosophical doctrines? The primary source is online. It’s there that the neophyte (beginner) must commence their quest. With a little searching using Duck Duck Go or some other search engine, one first starts by punching in the appropriate terms and following the trail of urls which will transport them, as surely as a yak up some Himalayan mountain slope, to the top of the mountain where they can gain a clearer vision of what lies hidden behind the clouds of illusion that the mainstream media has been manufacturing (like chemtrails) over the past century and longer. 

The adventures ahead for those with the intestinal fortitude to persevere are much too complex and too varied to even attempt to outline in this short editorial. It’s my plan though to publish some recent, relevant articles that will give interested folks a glimpse of what I’ve been talking about and from there one might find it easier to continue to search for the answers that have been hidden from us for much too long. Bon voyage!


Dr. Henry is the biggest liar in B.C. – she knows there is no virus!

Submitted by

Marcie Crozier and Family


Let’s talk about the elephant in the room…the big lie. Premier Horgan, have you bothered to ask Dr. Henry if her staff have found the corona virus yet? If Dr. Henry’s people have found the virus, they’re not sharing this information with Health Canada, because Christine Massey has received confirmation from Health Canada that they have no proof of the virus. https://www.fluoridefreepeel.ca/health-canada-has-no-record-of-covid-19-virus-isolation/ Mr. Dix, as Dr. Henry’s boss, will her next performance review question her knowledge of the existence of viruses? Have any of you asked Ms. Hajdu and Dr. Tam on what they based their declaration of a pandemic in Canada? Anyone? If the virus has not been detected, HOW CAN THERE BE A PANDEMIC? This is not a rhetorical question!

Dr. Knauss has a PhD in virology and immunology and tested 1500 samples of so called corona virus, using the gold standard: Koch’s Postulates. Are Doctors Tam and Henry even aware of Koch’s Postulates? https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Koch%27s_postulates  Dr. Henry is well aware that Dr. Knauss did not find a virus in any of these 1500 samples, and if she says she isn’t privy to this knowledge, she is either lying or she and/or her staff are highly incompetent as Dr. Knauss’s work has been available for some time now and is no secret. Is Dr. Henry even bothering to pursue proof of the existence of the virus? Dr. Knauss confirms his proof in this video, which is under 4 minutes long: https://www.brighteon.com/2833a107-84e0-48d4-8467-2b9d44ccca80  This article describes his project: https://rightsfreedoms.wordpress.com/2021/02/15/im-a-clinical-lab-scientist-covid-19-is-fake-wake-up-america/  Christine Massey’s multiple documents from hospitals and scientific institutions around the world confirm the same: https://www.fluoridefreepeel.ca/wp-content/uploads/2020/11/FOI-responses-re-covid19-virus-isolation-purification-34-institutions-Nov-11-2020-chrono.pdf  Christine Massey continues to collect this data. Her email address is Christine.Massey@protonmail.com if any of you care to receive future documents confirming the non-existence of this deadly killer virus you all are lying about. Dr. Henry or one of her staff might want to consider getting on this email list!

Here’s the ten million person study confirming there is no asymptomatic spread of this so called virus: https://www.lifesitenews.com/news/asymptomatic-transmission-of-covid-19-didnt-occur-at-all-study-of-10-million-finds  THIS PROVES LOCKDOWNS DO NOTHING!  Having said that, please feel free to further restrict the good people of B.C. because your most recent restrictions did much to awake the fence sitters. Have any of you even bothered to find a gold standard study that proves viruses are contagious? I have, and there are none. Seriously, try and find one.

And then there’s this inconvenient letter – inconvenient to liars that is – from the 100+ doctors and scientists from 25 countries to the Europeans Medicines Agency (EMA), who state: “…failure to inform “vaccine” recipients of the risks and negligible benefits outlined here represents serious violations of medical ethics and citizens’ medical rights. Those violations are especially grave as all the risks we describe can be expected to increase with each re-vaccination, and each intervening corona virus exposure. This renders both repeated vaccination and common corona viruses dangerous to young and healthy age groups, for whom — in the absence of “vaccination” — COVID-19 poses no substantive risk…We remind the EMA that Nuremberg violations constitute crimes against humanity under the Geneva Convention. Crimes against humanity are deemed “the worst atrocities known to mankind”, and are prosecuted under the Rome Statute of the International Criminal Court. https://www.un.org/en/chronicle/article/role-international-criminal-court-ending-impunity-and-establishing-rule-law  Given the hundreds of millions and eventually billions of people who may be coerced into accepting these agents, the EMA, in persistently shrinking from open debate and the truth, will be seen by lawyers and historians as having actively assisted in crimes against humanity, with the full weight of the implications to all involved. We demand that you engage openly with us to ensure that the public have an objective understanding of the clinical risk profile of these gene-based interventions.”  https://doctors4covidethics.medium.com/rebuttal-letter-to-european-medicines-agency-from-doctors-for-covid-ethics-april-1-2021-7d867f0121e  Of course, like you all, the criminals at the EMA are also avoiding the real questions. If you have any doubt that people are being coerced, we heard from an LNG employee yesterday who was told he had to take the shot or he would lose his job. He felt he had no choice as he has to feed his family. Shame on you!

Once the public recovers from the fear you have been promoting, can you imagine the backlash that will be directed at you all, especially from those who have unwittingly either taken the vaccine or who have family members who have done so? Oh, wait, this is already happening in the UK: https://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-9469529/Mother-demands-answers-son-20-died-12-hours-receiving-Pfizer-jab.html

Has Dr. Henry bothered to honour the highly ethical and courageous Dr. Hoffe with a response yet? https://cariboosentinel.ca/2021/04/11/small-community-of-lytton-bc-has-one-person-dead-and-three-people-permanently-disabled-following-their-first-dose-of-experimental-moderna-gene-modification-vaccine/  Tough questions for liars!

So, in summary, make no mistake that you all are complicit in this massive pandemic fraud. And now the lot of you truly have blood on your hands by continuing to stand for this lie and promote these death shots – yes, that includes you Misters Arnold and Kyllo as you have been provided with the truth, and you chose to ignore it. The level of depravity of you all is shocking!


Marcie Crozier and family

Choose your leaders with wisdom and forethought. To be led by a coward is to be controlled by all that the coward fears. To be led by a fool is to be led by the opportunists who control the fool. To be led by a thief is to offer up your most precious treasures to be stolen. To be led by a liar is to ask to be told lies. To be led by a tyrant is to sell yourself and those you love into slavery.

~Octavia Butler

MONDAY, APRIL 19, 2021


Further to the letter below, Christine Massey has since received another response confirming that the covid-19/corona virus does not exist. This one is pretty big news as it comes from the U.S. CDC, the corporation that Dr. Henry’s office claims they follow the “science” of. https://www.fluoridefreepeel.ca/wp-content/uploads/2021/04/CDC-FOIA-request-response-influenza-purification.pdf  “Trust the science” you all say? Yes, yes, we do trust the real science. Why don’t you?

There is a very succinct definition of insanity: “Unsoundness of mind sufficient to render a person unfit to maintain a contractual or other legal relationship…”  Given that the word “person” means corporation, and corporation describes the Province of British Columbia (according to the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission’s website – see link following), the word “insanity” is a perfect word to describe the current state of the Government of the Province of British Columbia. https://www.sec.gov/cgi-bin/browse-edgar?company=province+of+british+columbia&owner=exclude&action=getcompany.

When will one of you – including the media – stand up to the huge lie and do the right thing? Already you all have buckets of blood on your hands with regard to the plethora of deaths and injuries resulting from these experimental mRNA gene therapies! https://drive.google.com/file/d/1YK0JR_lFy88Zu3rcC3L5NvL_Xr3ib6zY/view  We are aware that the bogus “state of emergency” is what allows you to push these experimental death shots!

The Nuremberg Code trials are already happening. Were you aware that the Nuremberg Code is actually part of Canadian law? “Canada is the only western country, [where] any international treaty rights must be incorporated into Canadian domestic law; court said any treaty right is a minimal constitutional protection and standard.” In other words, the standards in the Nuremberg code are not mere guidelines in Canada, they are actionable constitutional guarantees.” https://vaccinechoicecanada.com/exemptions/traiblazing-canadian-constitutional-lawyer-rocco-galati-fights-for-the-world/  In case any of your were unaware, Rocco Galati is one of Canada’s premier constitutional lawyers. https://www.canadianlawyermag.com/surveys-reports/top-25-most-influential-lawyers/the-top-25-most-influential-2015/269873

Were you aware that world renowned lawyer, Reiner Fuellmich, is setting up a class action lawsuit under the Nuremberg Code that will be available to all Canadians? https://unitynewsnetwork.co.uk/the-covid-19-crimes-against-humanity-class-action-lawsuit/ 

Either you rise above the gag order you have been placed under or you rise up for the good people of B.C., Canada and the world. It’s your choice: to be the hero of the people or someone who stayed silent. Do you all truly believe you will escape the sharp sound of the gavel?

Marcie Crozier and family